vault3rb0y wrote: ... You really dont think the shoot-to-handstand simulates the vault??? I see it being the BEST simulation of the top end of a vault there is. ...
3P0, it seems like we're talking in circles here. [sigh]
Of course the shoot-to-a-handstand is an EXCELLENT drill to simulate the extension part of the vault!!! I've said that on many, many other threads over the past year.
What DOESN'T matter is how you start the drill. You can either ...
1. Cast off first.
2. Do a kip and back uprise first.
3. Do a backswing and then a back uprise first.
4. Do it from a "very light swing" (your option).
5. Do it from a dead hang (Agapit's option).
These 5 options only get you to a point where you BEGIN the shoot-to-a-handstand. I've ranked them in order of difficulty.
If you're measuring ATHLETICISM (which Agapit was), then #5 is the one that requires the most athleticism.
If you're trying to simulate a real vault (which Agapit wasn't), then whichever one gets your hips the highest FIRST ... BEFORE the shoot-to-a-handstand begins ... would be the best. It's debatable which of #1-3 that would be ... but it's definitely not #4 or #5.
#4 (yours) is too difficult for mere mortals to do ... to the point that they would FAIL to actually do a proper shoot-to-a-handstand.
Ditto on #5 ... even if you COULD do it, you wouldn't have the speed that you have during a real vault, so it's not a good vault simulation drill ... it's just a measure of athleticism ... and good muscular conditioning.
In my training, I usually did the shoot-to-a-handstand from a kip/back-uprise (but sometimes from a cast-off). That was when I was trying to simulate an actual vault. But when I wanted to condition my muscles ... or measure how well I could do a shoot-to-a-handstand from a standing position under the bar ... I did #5. As I said, I could not SHOOT to a complete handstand this way. I could only get maybe three quarters the way up before I had to shift my hands and muscule up the rest of the way into a handstand.
I also mentioned in a different post that I used a variation of the shoot-to-a-handstand from a standing start as a sort of endurance contest ... to see how many times I could clear the bar and land back on my feet ... with no rest in-between reps ... without letting my chest scrape the bar. I forget exactly how many I could do, but it was around a dozen or so. If you don't have a good strength-to-weight ratio, you won't do well in this contest. I was a bit insane about this, and actually watched what I ate SO THAT I COULD DO MORE REPS! You'd think that my objective would be so that I'd vault higher ... and that WAS an end goal ... but along the way to that end goal, being able to do more reps without scraping my chest on the highbar was a self-measurement to see how my strength-to-weight ratio was improving. I know ... I was a little insane on this one ... but that's what I did.
I hope we're on the same page now.
Kirk