VaultPurple wrote:Andy, I agree with pretty much every thing you said except for where you said holding your position (delaying your swing to vertical) will not increase penetration. Now understand I am not condoning any vaulting model that encourages a delayed swing. But the physics behind a delayed swing are sound and true. This is because when you are in the take off position and hanging under the pole, your bodies center of mass is lower than when you swing up. When you swing up you increase your bodies potential energy, and because of conservation of energy, when potential energy increases, kinetic energy must decrease, which causes your bodies forward velocity to slow down.
This is why you sometimes see tuck and shoot vaulters with a delayed swing. They delay it long enough so that the pole is rolled into the pit, so that when they tuck it is already to vertical and will shoot them up. If they were to just tuck earlier, they would not go near as deep.
This also works somewhat with a swing vaulter in a mental since but I do not know the exact amount of energy the swing puts into the vault in relation to the decrease in velocity caused by raising your center of mass. But a lot of people may have noticed that they can do a jogadan and land on the pit with a very large pole, but when they try to invert with this pole (usually with bad technique because they are getting used to the new pole) they find that they do not land near as deep in the pit.
Hi VP,
Here's the way I see it.
Something always has to happen somewhere, no dead zones. When you swing, your trail leg will be swung down which will give you much more penetration than simply hanging down with your trail leg behind you. This is the main reason why people drop their front leg, doing so will drop the total center of mass down. When you go up, yes you will not be able todo much if you tuck and shoot! However if you have very good technique, the hip thrusting upwards will add more energy to the system.
Try and watch somebody with a very good swing on one of those fiberglass bars in gymnastics. You will see the bar bend quite noticeably, more compared to just hanging there. Just be careful not to break the bar! If the technique is extremely good, the bar will even bend upwards with the hip thrust. Most importantly for this discussion, there is more total pressure downward for a good portion of the swing compared to just hanging. One other important point that should not be overlooked is the displacement of the center of mass relative to the pole. When you swing, your body will move forward on the way up in a pendulum effect. You are still exerting pressure on the pole by swinging, it does not disappear once you leave the position. You will be achieving less by holding.
Yes I agree that there has to a a time to "deposit" the energy into the pole so to speak. The problem is that I think people often watch too many slow-mo videos. It's easy to describe if it's happening at 120 frames per second, but doing so may take the action out of context. Even when coaches talk about intricacies and break down the vault for an athlete, they often try to describe way too much. The vault, especially anything in the air, happens extremely quickly. Don't get me wrong, a coach will need to break it down. It must always be on the back of the coach and vaulter's mind that time is of the essence. By the time you have achieved that good stretching position, enough energy has already gone in - and more will go in by virtue of of momentum as long as you keep a solid body and don't let go. By the time you even get a thought off that you need to wait here and penetrate more, you're already too late with regards to the swing. If the swing is not fast enough, you cannot reach the good position on top of the pole - you run out of time and momentum. Considering how few people in history (maybe a very small handful of elites - ever) can reach this position, I think people should be more vigilant about the temporality of the pole vault. That is not to say, rush everything. Just do it, be definite, no waiting and do it swiftly. Everything in the air is a blur, go ask Bubka. His response to the question was actually quite comical if you can find it.
Finally, we use the stretch position as a *biomechanical marker* to indicate - ok, now swing. It is immediate and there is no thinking involved. There is no time for an arbitrary decision of - "ok, wait.. wait.. alright, go!" Especially with the coaches game plans during a meet "ok, in that jump it wasn't long enough, hold it a little longer." What amount of time qualifies as "a little longer?" Vaulters are not atomic clocks. This promotes inconsistency. You need something physical and definitive, "feel the stretch = pull the trigger" Zero thinking and immediate reaction. The athlete is a human being of course, but the vault must be executed with absolute machine-like precision. And that attitude is not only applicable in this part of the vault, but throughout the whole thing with other biomechanical markers in the run, plant and take off. The vaulter need to be a machine, and not just in the "aww, you're an animal bro!" sense.
Hope that clarifies my position.
-Andrew