Page 1 of 3
Q about a Rule- Passing your last attempt.
Posted: Thu Mar 20, 2008 10:55 pm
by primetime614
say you past your last attempt at a height and make it then you make it again, but the guy you are vaulting aganist ties you at the top height but made it on his second attempt at the next to highest hight, who wins???
like this
Vaulter A - O XXP O XXO
Vaulter B - O XO XO XXO
Posted: Fri Mar 21, 2008 12:19 am
by higherflyer
I think that A wins by making same height as b but on his first jump at that height.
Posted: Fri Mar 21, 2008 2:47 am
by rainbowgirl28
They tie. They tied at the winning height and had the same number of total misses.
If they were the last athletes in the competition, it would be time for a jumpoff!
Posted: Fri Mar 21, 2008 11:59 am
by newPVer
Becca, Do you have the official rule number for this answer? I have always thought that the person with the most recent miss would be the looser.
Thanks
Posted: Fri Mar 21, 2008 12:12 pm
by achtungpv
No. And your starting height doesn't matter either.
It is misses at final height and then overall number of misses.
I have a memory from HS of:
*deleted because old rules don't matter*
I'm not sure if those were rules back in the day or just a poor knowledge of the rules that is still passed on.
Posted: Fri Mar 21, 2008 12:28 pm
by Vaultref
It would be best for all to not bring up old rules or what might have been old rules to determine the the places. It only matters what it is today.
I still hear young athletes say they really thought you go back to the
previous height to determine who won or placed heigher.
Don't know where they have heard this or read it, but it's a myth that needs to be busted!
Posted: Fri Mar 21, 2008 2:06 pm
by rainbowgirl28
Vaultref wrote:It would be best for all to not bring up old rules or what might have been old rules to determine the the places. It only matters what it is today.
I still hear young athletes say they really thought you go back to the
previous height to determine who won or placed heigher.
Don't know where they have heard this or read it, but it's a myth that needs to be busted!
I agree. It is too confusing to have people posting what they think is right or what it used to be. It is important to only have the correct information online. I cannot believe how often people screw something this simple up.
Posted: Sun Mar 23, 2008 11:08 am
by BethelPV
Doesn't this also depend on how the state has set up their rules as well? My dad is a coach in Michigan and told me that Michigan actually has their own rule book aside from that of the high school federation. The Michigan rule book says that you are supposed to go back to the previous height... it doesn't say anything about counting the total misses. So what would you suggest to do in a situation like that?
Posted: Sun Mar 23, 2008 11:59 am
by VaultPurple
o what is the official way to determine who wins if there is a tie at the finial height?
whoever got the last height in the most tries?
and if they have it in same tries you count total scraches?
so making the last height on your first try even though you scrached twice at every height befor that beats someone that scrached for the first time at the finial height?
because i was in a meet this year that i scratched twice at 11'6, once at 12', none at 12'6, and none at 13'.... and the other guy made all his jumps on the first try except for 13' where it took him all 3 tries..... so who should have won?.... at the meet they gave it to the other guy
Posted: Sun Mar 23, 2008 12:04 pm
by bayouvaulter
I can go back to 1974 and in Louisiana we used the same rules that apply today, because that's how I won state my junior year in a tie and jump off.
I can't say about rules before then but they must be pretty old rules!
Posted: Sun Mar 23, 2008 3:00 pm
by Vaultref
BethelPV wrote:Doesn't this also depend on how the state has set up their rules as well? My dad is a coach in Michigan and told me that Michigan actually has their own rule book aside from that of the high school federation. The Michigan rule book says that you are supposed to go back to the previous height... it doesn't say anything about counting the total misses. So what would you suggest to do in a situation like that?
If this is the case, and I have no reason to doubt it, then you have no choice but to use the rules of your state when the meet is held in your state.
I've worked meets with officials who live in Michigan (not high school level) and none ever said the placement rules were different. I'll contact an official/PV coach I know and ask for myself. Why they would do this is not clear as all the other four rule codes handle the situation the same way.
Posted: Sun Mar 23, 2008 3:05 pm
by Vaultref
VaultPurple wrote:o what is the official way to determine who wins if there is a tie at the finial height?
whoever got the last height in the most tries?
and if they have it in same tries you count total scratches?
so making the last height on your first try even though you scratched twice at every height before that beats someone that scratched for the first time at the finial height?
because i was in a meet this year that i scratched twice at 11'6, once at 12', none at 12'6, and none at 13'.... and the other guy made all his jumps on the first try except for 13' where it took him all 3 tries..... so who should have won?.... at the meet they gave it to the other guy
In your example, at the tied height of 13', you win because your clearance was on your first attempt. Plain and simple. Where was the meet and was this a meet sanctioned by NFHS or USATF or no sancation at all.